User blog:Perchan/Message Walls vs Talk Pages: Civil War

AYYYOOOOOOOOOOO WHO'S HYPED FOR CAPTAIN AMERICA CIVIL WAR

Anyway, let's get down to business, to defeat

THE HUNS

But seriously, I'm sorry we never got around to this sooner, everyone. It's actually been in the works since 2013 when somebody'd mention it and it'd get shot down, but now since we're aiming for more user involvement in how the wiki works to make everyone satisfied with their time here, I'm just going to hold a community vote and we can see where it leads.

I'll get straight to it, no flowery stuff. We're probably one of the five hundred wikis who still uses talk pages, some are satisfied with this, some aren't, hence why this is being held, to see what people think.

What do you prefer?

Talk Pages, which is what we have now, or Message Walls, which many other wikis have. In any case, if you don't know, a message wall is more like a social media thing such as Facebook, where you write a post on somebody else's wall, but you need to put a topic name first.

Alternatively, I've received a third option- what if we still use talk pages, but we organize them, like for example, mine will have a Magic Request section and a normal talk section. This'll have to be done manually, and of course, it's optional- if you don't want to organize your talk page like this, then you don't have to.

I won't put up a poll for this since polls can be easily abused, but please comment on what you want more, Talk Pages, Message Walls, or Talk Pages which can also function as Message Walls more or less Talk Pages where everything is neatly organized.

Personally, I prefer talk pages how they are, but to be honest, I don't really care about what we use as long as the message gets through and everyone's happy.

Again, please comment below, reasoning is optional. Thanks for involving yourself with this!