Talk:Phoenix Slayer Magic/@comment-27669396-20160310204926/@comment-24384232-20160310225822

Thats a matter of personal opinion Yami with no canonical basis at all. Can a Phoenix Slayer defeat a Dragon? Depends entirely on the circumstances, who has what kind of advantages, where the fight is taking place etc. But if we go by the notion that a Dragon Slayer is the only being capable of harming a dragon I would say no. Same reason that a Phoenix Slayer is the only being that can slay a Phoenix.

The whole arc where Natsu one-shotted a God is a very very rare exception to this clause and in no way should this be considered applicable for the fanon. Gods need God Slayers to beat them. Dragons need Dragon Slayers and so on and so forth. Remember Dragons have ridiculous levels of magic resistance, and the only thing capable of bypassing that is the magic of a Dragon Slayer. I assume the same goes for the other species.

Unless you're one of them or have their brand of magic, most of your magic is going to bounce harmlessly off their hides and they will in turn laugh at you, before proceeding to curbstomp you.